What Is the CMS PY 2023 Medicare Advantage RADV Audit, and What Should Provider Groups Do?

Amanda McGurk

12 min read · November 16, 2026

Photograph of a hospital health information specialist pulling a closed chart folder from a filing drawer, representing a Medicare Advantage RADV medical records request.

Written by Amanda McGurk · Published 16 November 2026 · Last reviewed 16 November 2026

Reviewed by: Jessica Miller, MHA, CPC, CPC-I, Head of Coding Operations

CMS opened Payment Year 2023 Medicare Advantage RADV audits on November 13, 2026. Plans can download the Enrollee Data List on November 30 and must submit medical records from December 4, 2026, to April 23, 2027. Providers send their 2022 charts to the plan, not to CMS.

ItemDate or ruleWhat it means for your team
Audit cycle openedNovember 13, 2026Plans holding audited contracts start building provider request lists
Enrollee Data List (EDL) in CDATNovember 30, 2026Record requests to your office can follow within days
Medical record windowDecember 4, 2026 to April 23, 2027, 11:59 p.m. ESTYour turnaround eats into the plan's review time before its deadline
Hardship exception deadlineMay 7, 2027, 11:59 p.m. ESTA plan-only request; provider non-response does not qualify
Dates of service auditedJanuary 1 to December 31, 2022Four-year-old charts, signatures and credentials get tested
Sample per contract35, 50, 100 or 200 enrolleesEach audited contract sends a bounded, named list, not a census
Record limit2 records per audited HCC per enrolleePlans will ask for the strongest record, not every encounter
Audited contracts582 contract IDs under 135 parent organizationsCheck the list against the MA plans your patients carry

Dates, sample sizes and record rules come from the CMS PY 2023 RADV Audit Methods and Instructions (version 1, November 13, 2026). We counted the contracts in the CMS PY 2023 list of audited contracts on 15 November 2026.

What is a Medicare Advantage RADV audit?

A Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV) audit is the CMS review that checks whether the diagnoses a Medicare Advantage organization reported for risk-adjusted payment are supported in the medical record. Under 42 CFR 422.310(e), plans and their providers must submit a sample of records for that check. When a diagnosis does not hold up, the hierarchical condition category (HCC) it produced comes off the enrollee's risk score, and CMS calculates an overpayment.

PY 2023 payments rest on diagnoses from 2022 dates of service, scored under the V24 CMS-HCC model. For a refresher on how HCCs work, see our guide to HCC coding . This post covers only the PY 2023 cycle.

Why a plan audit lands on your HIM desk

The audit notice goes to the plan's CEO, CFO, COO and Medicare compliance officer. The records it needs sit in your EHR. The methods state that the MA organization "must request MRs from hospitals and physicians/practitioners who provided services to enrollees and documented diagnoses associated with audited HCCs" during 2022.

That request reaches HIM teams already working current-year release-of-information volume. CMS runs overlapping cycles, too. The RADV audit schedule shows PY 2020, PY 2021 and PY 2024 already open, with PY 2022 planned for January to February 2027 and PY 2025 for April to May 2027. A group with patients in several MA plans can expect requests from more than one plan, for more than one year, at the same time.

What changed on November 13, 2026

CMS published the PY 2023 methods, the audited contract list and an updated RADV Questions and Answers document on the same day. Three details matter to provider-side teams.

The sample is targeted. CMS did not draw from every member. The frame covers enrollees continuously enrolled from January 2022 through January 2023, with 12 months of Part B in 2022 and at least one 2022 diagnosis that mapped to a PY 2023 HCC. It excludes ESRD and hospice status and C-SNP, I-SNP and FIDE-SNP enrollment. Enrollees must also rank in the top quartile of CMS's PY 2023 improper payment prediction models, meaning CMS predicted the largest risk score drop for them. CMS then drew a random sample of 35 to 200 enrollees per contract, by contract size.

Records go to the plan. In Q13 of the updated Q&A, CMS says records sent to CMS "other than through the secure RADV system, the Central Data Abstraction Tool (CDAT), will not be used." Only a point of contact the plan authorizes can upload. Q14 tells plans to send providers a letter with the CMS Provider MR Request Memo, a deadline and a contact.

Collection of extrapolated amounts is still open. CMS designed the PY 2023 audits to calculate an extrapolated overpayment. At results issuance, it will collect the sum of errors on sampled enrollees if that sum is above $0, and it "reserves the right to collect extrapolated overpayments at a later date" if legally permissible. The 2023 rule that set RADV extrapolation policy (CMS-4185-F2) was vacated in Humana Inc. v. Becerra (N.D. Tex. 2025), and the appeal is pending in the Fifth Circuit, No. 25-11293.

What makes a 2022 record valid for RADV

A valid record is a legibly signed record of a face-to-face visit with an acceptable provider type during 2022 that supports the audited HCC. CMS coders abstract each record under the ICD-10-CM Official Guidelines and AHA Coding Clinic, with up to three independent reviews when the first review does not validate an HCC.

The methods set packaging rules your release-of-information team should know:

  • Outpatient and physician records cover one date of service per PDF. A health risk assessment counts as this type.
  • Inpatient records need an admission date, a discharge date inside 2022 and a signed discharge summary.
  • Telehealth diagnoses can meet the face-to-face rule for 2022 when the visit used interactive audio and video, per the May 4, 2022 HPMS memo the methods cite.
  • Invalid sources include hospice, home health, lab-only records, superbills and non-face-to-face encounters.
  • Missing signatures or credentials can be fixed only with a completed CMS-generated attestation.

A missing credential, a wrong patient or an unsigned note fails intake before any coder reads the diagnosis. Your team should catch those three before the PDF leaves the building.

A plan recovery is different from a provider clawback

CMS recovers RADV overpayments from the Medicare Advantage organization. It does not bill the physician group or hospital. Any exposure for a provider comes from the provider's own contract with the plan, such as a risk-sharing, capitation or delegated-coding agreement. Some contracts pass audit adjustments through. Others say nothing.

The second distinction is about direction. RADV only removes payment. Methods section 9.3 states that "a RADV audit will not result in additional payments being made to an MA organization." Finding an HCC the plan never reported does not offset a discrepancy, so searching 2022 charts for missed conditions does nothing for this audit.

What should HIM, coding and revenue cycle leaders do before December 4, 2026?

Use the weeks before the record window opens to set up one clean path for plan requests.

  1. Name one intake owner. Route every MA "medical record validation" or RADV request to one HIM or RCM queue with a named person, so letters from different plans do not scatter across departments.
  2. Match the enrollee and the year. Pull the record for the named enrollee and a 2022 date of service tied to the requested HCC. CMS treats a record for the wrong person as invalid and a PHI problem.
  3. Check signature, credentials and source. Confirm the rendering provider signed with credentials, and that the encounter type is a valid source. Flag gaps so the plan can request a CMS attestation.
  4. Package by record type. One outpatient date of service per PDF. Inpatient files carry admission and discharge dates and the signed discharge summary.
  5. Send to the plan contact only. Return records to the address in the plan's letter. Do not send them to CMS or a RADV mailbox.
  6. Log every response. Record date received, date sent, what you sent and why a record could not be found. CMS methods Appendix B lists provider non-response, lost records and ordinary IT problems as grounds CMS does not accept for a plan hardship exception.
  7. Read your MA contracts now. Finance and contracting should find any clause on risk adjustment audits, RADV or overpayment pass-through before findings arrive.

Contracted providers also fall under the 10-year record retention terms that plans must flow down under 42 CFR 422.504(i). A lapsed state retention period does not count as a hardship.

Where MediCodio AI fits

MediCodio AI does not run RADV audits, upload to CDAT or retrieve records for plans. It supports the part of the problem your coding team owns going forward: diagnosis codes that match what the documentation supports, with the evidence attached. CODIO AI, the engine behind MediCodio AI's AI medical coding , reads the documentation, separates ruled-out conditions from confirmed ones and assigns ICD-10-CM codes under the official guidelines. Every code ships with its documentation passage and the compliance rule behind it, a 100% code-level audit trail your HIM team can pull when a plan asks why a code was reported.

Complete charts flow through AutoPilot for fully autonomous coding. Charts where the documentation is thin or contradictory stay in CoPilot, where certified coders review and finalize the output. Nothing runs autonomous on day one. Everything starts in review, and the autonomous lane widens only as accuracy is proven on your own charts.

Teams in MA risk arrangements can see how we work with physician groups , health systems and RCM companies . For ongoing risk adjustment work outside an audit, see our overview of risk adjustment coding services .

What has not changed

ICD-10-CM guidelines and the medical record still decide whether a diagnosis is supported, as they did in 2022. The record submission duty in 42 CFR 422.310(e) predates the vacated 2023 rule. CMS still audits the plan, not the practice. Nobody can change the 2022 documentation now. Your team controls whether the right records are found, packaged and returned on time.

Frequently asked questions

Is my hospital or medical group on the CMS list of audited contracts?

No. The CMS workbook lists Medicare Advantage contracts and their parent organizations, not provider groups. If your patients were enrolled in one of the 582 audited contracts and fell into the sample, the plan may ask you for 2022 records. You will learn you are in scope when a plan request arrives.

What dates of service does the PY 2023 RADV audit review?

Calendar year 2022. Payment Year 2023 risk-adjusted payments were built from diagnoses with dates of service from January 1 through December 31, 2022, under the V24 CMS-HCC model. A visit from 2023 or later cannot validate a PY 2023 audited HCC, so pull the 2022 encounter that documented the condition.

Do we send RADV medical records to CMS or to the health plan?

Send them to the health plan. Only a point of contact the Medicare Advantage organization authorizes can upload records into the CMS CDAT system. In its November 13, 2026 Q&A update, CMS said records a provider or vendor sends directly to CMS will not be used for the audit.

What if we cannot find a 2022 record the plan requested?

Tell the plan in writing and look for another valid 2022 source, such as a different visit that documented the same condition. CMS does not accept provider non-response, lost records, ordinary IT problems or a lapsed state retention period as hardship grounds, and the plan still needs a supporting record.

Will CMS extrapolate PY 2023 RADV overpayments?

CMS will calculate an extrapolated amount but has not decided whether to collect it. At results issuance, it collects the sum of errors on sampled enrollees if that sum is above $0, and reserves the right to collect an extrapolated amount later if legally permissible. The 2023 extrapolation rule was vacated and is on appeal.

Book a Demo and we will run an accuracy check on a sample of your own charts, showing the documentation passage and rule behind every code, so your HIM team can see how your diagnosis coding holds up against the record. Book a Demo

Related reading: HCC coding explained · AI risk adjustment coding · MediCodio AI for hospitals

Sources

See it in action

Ready to transform your medical coding?

See how MediCodio's AI platform delivers 98%+ accuracy across deployments since 2023, with turnaround under 24 hours at enterprise volume, inclusive of coder review, across 35+ specialties.

Loading posts...